Tonglen Meditation Steps: Breathing In Pain, Breathing Out Relief

Almost every relaxation exercise you have come across runs in one direction: breathe in calm, breathe out tension. Tonglen turns that around. On the in-breath you take in suffering, imagined as something heavy and dark. On the out-breath you send out relief, imagined as something light and cool. The first reaction is often a small recoil. Why would anyone breathe in pain on purpose?

The answer lies in what the practice is trying to change. Tonglen is not a technique for feeling pleasant. It trains you to turn toward difficulty instead of away from it, and to loosen the reflex that splits experience into "mine to protect" and "theirs to avoid." Seen that way, the reversed breath stops looking odd and starts looking exact.

Origins

Tonglen is a Tibetan word usually translated as "sending and taking" or "giving and receiving." It belongs to the lojong, or mind training, teachings of Mahayana Buddhism, which reached Tibet in the eleventh century and were later condensed into the well-known Seven Points of Mind Training attributed to Geshe Chekawa. In the West it became widely known through teachers such as Pema Chödrön, whose instructions many English-speaking practitioners still follow.

The practice sits inside the wider Buddhist cultivation of compassion; you can think of it as compassion given a breath and a direction. Our piece on the spiritual practice of compassion covers that broader ground.

Four stages

Teachers vary in their instructions, but a widely taught sequence has four stages. A first session might last ten to fifteen minutes altogether.

StageWhat you doRoughly how long at first
1. OpenRest for a moment in stillness and spaciousness before doing anythingA few breaths
2. TextureBreathe in heaviness, heat and darkness; breathe out lightness, coolness and brightnessA couple of minutes
3. SpecificApply the breath to one real situation or personThe main part of the session
4. WidenExtend to everyone who feels the same kind of painA few minutes

A moment of openness

Sit quietly and let the mind be open for a moment, without any object. Some teachers call this a brief glimpse of spacious awareness. It does not have to be profound. It simply gives what follows a roomy mind to happen in instead of a cramped one.

Texture

Before bringing in any story, practise the mechanics. Breathing in, imagine drawing in something hot, thick and heavy, like smoke. Breathing out, imagine releasing something cool, clear and light. Some instructions say to breathe in through every pore of the body and radiate out through every pore. Keep it physical and simple. This stage lets you get used to the reversal before any emotion is attached to it.

If smoke and light feel contrived, use whatever works for you: heaviness and lightness, tightness and ease. The image serves the practice, not the other way round.

One real situation

Now choose something specific. Traditionally people often begin with someone they care about who is struggling: a grieving friend, an ill parent. Breathe in their pain, as if lifting it off their shoulders. Breathe out whatever you imagine would bring them relief: ease, warmth, rest, space.

You can also start with your own difficulty. If you are anxious, breathe the anxiety in fully, then breathe out spaciousness for yourself. Many teachers recommend exactly this, because it keeps the practice honest. It is hard to breathe in someone else's fear while refusing to feel your own. The mind training tradition generally encourages including yourself, not out of selfishness but because an open heart has no exceptions. Practitioners who skip themselves are missing part of the method.

Many people also practise tonglen for someone who has died. It can be a meaningful way to work with grief: breathe in your own sorrow and the sorrow of others who loved that person, and breathe out peace and gratitude.

Widening the circle

Finally, let it spread. Think of everyone who, right now, feels what you or your chosen person feels. People in hospital waiting rooms. People lying awake with the same worry. Breathe in for all of them; breathe out for all of them. This is where tonglen does something unusual: personal pain becomes a doorway to connection instead of a wall of isolation.

A script to lean on

Some people find words helpful. Read these slowly, or record them in your own voice:

  • Sit comfortably. Let the breath find its own rhythm. Rest for a few breaths with nothing to do.
  • Breathe in heaviness, like warm dark smoke. Breathe out lightness, like cool clear air. Continue for a minute.
  • Bring to mind someone who is hurting. See their face. Breathe in their pain. Breathe out relief toward them.
  • If resistance appears, breathe in the resistance too. Breathe out openness.
  • Think of everyone who shares this kind of suffering. Breathe in for all of them. Breathe out for all of them.
  • Let the images go. Rest in the breath for a minute before opening your eyes.

Is it safe to breathe in other people's pain?

This is the most common worry, and it deserves a direct answer. In tonglen you are working with imagination and intention. You are not literally absorbing anyone's illness or misfortune, and the tradition does not claim you are. What the practice works on is your own reactivity, the habit of flinching from whatever is unpleasant.

Even so, tonglen can stir strong emotion. People who care for others, at work or at home, sometimes find it adds to their exhaustion if they do it without balance. If the practice leaves you drained rather than softened, shorten it, start with your own difficulties or set it aside for a while.

If you are living with trauma, severe depression or overwhelming anxiety, tonglen may not be the place to begin. Deliberately calling up painful material can make distress worse. Speak to a qualified mental health professional, and to an experienced meditation teacher, before you take it up.

Common mistakes

One is trying to feel heroic. Tonglen is not a test of how much suffering you can carry. It is quiet, ordinary and repeated.

Another is keeping it for formal sessions only. Tonglen can be done in a few breaths in daily life: in a queue behind someone who is struggling, or when bad news arrives. Brief, on-the-spot practice was part of how it was taught from the beginning.

Tonglen and loving-kindness

Loving-kindness, or metta, usually works by repeating phrases of goodwill toward yourself and others. Tonglen uses the breath and explicitly takes in suffering before sending out relief. Both build warmth, but tonglen faces pain more directly.

How often should a beginner practise? A few short sessions a week is a reasonable start; consistency counts for more than length, and if ten minutes feels heavy, five is enough. You can learn the basic form from books and recordings, but guidance from an experienced teacher helps, especially if strong emotion comes up or you want to go further into the mind training teachings.

Try it once this week, for one person you care about, for no more than ten minutes. Notice what happens in your body when you breathe in instead of bracing, and what happens when you breathe out something kind. The practice does not ask you to fix anyone's pain. It asks you to stop turning away from it, one breath at a time.

This article is for general information about a contemplative practice and is not medical or psychological advice. If you are struggling with your mental health, please contact a qualified professional.

Comments

About the author

Ender Çene
Ender Çene
Dijital yayıncı ve içerik editörü. Bu sitedeki yazılar editöryel inceleme sürecinden geçer.