Picture two people sitting side by side in a quiet room. Both have their eyes closed. Both are still. Both, every so often, notice that their minds have wandered and gently come back. From the outside, they are doing exactly the same thing. One is practising centering prayer. The other is practising mindfulness meditation. Are they?
The question matters to many people: Christians curious about meditation who worry it might conflict with their faith, secular meditators who wonder whether prayer is just meditation with religious language, and anyone trying to choose a contemplative practice that fits their life. In brief, the two practices share a great deal of technique but differ in intention, and the difference in intention shapes the experience more than you might expect.
What centering prayer is
Centering prayer is a Christian contemplative practice developed in the 1970s by Trappist monks, most prominently Thomas Keating, William Meninger and Basil Pennington. They drew on older sources, especially the fourteenth-century English text The Cloud of Unknowing and the wider tradition of Christian contemplation, and shaped them into a simple method for lay people.
Its core is consent. The practitioner chooses a short "sacred word," such as "God," "Jesus," "peace" or "love," as a symbol of their intention to consent to God's presence and action within. The word is not a mantra to be repeated continuously. It is used only when the mind has become engaged with thoughts, as a gentle way of renewing that intention.
The basic guidelines
- Choose a sacred word as the symbol of your intention to consent to God's presence and action within.
- Sit comfortably with eyes closed, settle briefly, and silently introduce the sacred word.
- When you become engaged with thoughts, including feelings, images and sensations, return ever so gently to the sacred word.
- At the end of the prayer period, remain in silence with eyes closed for a couple of minutes.
Teachers in this tradition commonly recommend a period of about twenty minutes, often twice a day.
What mindfulness meditation is
Mindfulness meditation, as widely taught today, has roots in Buddhist practice, particularly in insight traditions, and has also been adapted into secular programmes. It generally involves paying attention to present-moment experience, such as the breath, body sensations, sounds or thoughts, with an attitude of openness and non-judgement.
The intention is usually framed as awareness itself: seeing clearly what is happening, moment to moment, and developing a different relationship to it. In its Buddhist context, this clarity is linked to insight into the nature of experience and the end of suffering. In secular contexts, it may be framed around wellbeing, focus or emotional balance.
Side by side
| Centering prayer | Mindfulness meditation | |
|---|---|---|
| Tradition | Christian contemplative | Buddhist roots; also secular forms |
| Core intention | Consent to God's presence and action | Clear, non-judgemental awareness of experience |
| Role of attention | Attention is not the goal; intention is | Training attention is central |
| Anchor | Sacred word, used only when needed | Often the breath or body, returned to continually |
| Attitude to thoughts | Let them pass; do not engage, resist or examine | Notice and sometimes investigate them |
| Relationship | Explicitly relational: with God | Usually not framed as relational |
| Typical session | About twenty minutes | Varies widely |
The key difference: attention vs intention
In mindfulness, the quality of attention is the practice. You notice the breath as precisely as you can; when you wander, you return. In centering prayer, the emphasis is almost the opposite. The practitioner is not trying to focus on anything, not even the sacred word. What matters is the intention of consenting to God, and the word is simply a way of renewing that intention when thoughts take over.
Teachers in this tradition stress that thoughts are inevitable and that each return to the sacred word is itself an act of consent. The practice cannot be done badly by having many thoughts, because returning is the prayer.
Investigation vs letting go
Many mindfulness approaches invite you to look at thoughts and sensations: to notice what they are, how they arise, how they pass. Centering prayer asks you not to examine thoughts during the prayer period at all, but to let them float by. Insights may come later, but analysing during the prayer is considered a distraction from its purpose. That emphasis on releasing rather than studying resonates with the sacred practice of letting go.
What they share
Despite these differences, the practices share a surprising amount.
- Both involve sitting in silence with a simple method of returning.
- Both treat wandering as normal rather than as failure.
- Both cultivate a kind of inner stillness that can carry into daily life, the quality explored in our essay on the art of stillness.
- Both can reveal a quieter observing presence behind the flow of thoughts, what some contemplatives call the inner witness.
- Both are best learned with some guidance and practised consistently.
Choosing between them
A few questions can help you decide.
- Is your practice rooted in a faith? If you are Christian and want your contemplative life to deepen your relationship with God, centering prayer was designed for exactly that.
- Are you looking for a practice without religious framing? Secular mindfulness may suit you better.
- Do you want to train attention and study your mind? Mindfulness offers more tools for that.
- Do you find effortful focus tiring or anxious? Many people find the gentle, low-effort quality of centering prayer a relief.
- Can you do both? Some people do: mindfulness practice for attention training, centering prayer as a devotional practice. Others find it clearer to commit to one.
Trying both fairly
A fair comparison needs time. Consider spending two weeks with each practice rather than alternating daily. Keep the same time of day and the same seat so that only the method changes. During the mindfulness weeks, notice how precise your attention becomes. During the centering prayer weeks, notice whether the quality of your intention, the simple willingness to be present to God, shifts anything in how you meet the rest of the day. Write a line or two after each session. At the end, your own notes will tell you more than any comparison table.
Common questions
Is centering prayer just meditation with a Christian label?
Practitioners and teachers of centering prayer generally say no. While the outward form resembles some meditation techniques, its purpose is relational: it is understood as prayer, a way of being with God, rather than a technique for training the mind.
Can a Christian practise mindfulness meditation?
Many Christians do, often in secular forms focused on attention and wellbeing. Views vary between churches and individuals. If you have concerns, talking with a pastor or spiritual director in your tradition is a sensible step.
Is centering prayer the same as transcendental meditation?
No. Transcendental Meditation uses a mantra repeated as the object of meditation within its own organisation's teaching. In centering prayer, the sacred word is not repeated continuously and is not a mantra; it is a symbol of intention used only when needed.
How long does it take to learn centering prayer?
The method can be learned in a single session. Living with it is the longer work. Many practitioners describe it as a practice they keep discovering over years.
Same silence, different doors
Return to the two people sitting side by side. Their breath, their stillness and their gentle returning may look identical. One is attending closely to experience, learning to see clearly. The other is resting in a silent yes to a presence she understands as God. Both are entering silence, and both may come out gentler and more awake. They simply arrived through different doors, and it is worth knowing which door you are choosing, and why.
Comments
Post a Comment